Hi all
this is a post with an example file showing Part WB Loft and Sweep GUI tool problems/limitations/bugs.
I wanted to make a dinning room chair back. So I tried 5 different approaches, the first worked but with a face rendered past the end on the ellipse and only the last worked perfectly.
1) I tried to loft from one Part ellipse to another and could only get a surface even with "make solid" ticked
2) as described here viewtopic.php?f=10&t=2762 I created a top and bottom ellipse from Part create primitives, then used Part Shape Builder to create a Part Face from the ellipse. The face was longer than the ellipse (a bug), still I lofted (but only got a surface surface) between the two ellipses, then got the two faces from ellipses and the loft surface, then added them together to make a shell in Part Shape Builder, then used Part Shape Builder again to make the shell into a solid. This did work except that the top and bottom ellipses did render to long in the x direction.
3) I made a top sketch and a bottom sketch. Loft between sketches also only made a surface despite having ticked "make solid"
4) then I created a sketch for a path and used Part Sweep with the two ellipses and the sketch for Path, it worked except that is would not make a solid even though "make solid" was ticked, so I only got a surface again.
5) this finally worked, I created a sketch for the top and another for the bottom, then another sketch for the path, I then used Part Sweep from one sketch to the other using the third as the Path and ticked "make solid" which produced a solid.
I have made a mantis ticket for this, here: -
https://sourceforge.net/apps/mantisbt/f ... php?id=768
this is the file containing the examples.
Jim
Part WB Loft and Sweep GUI tool problems limitations bugs
Forum rules
Be nice to others! Respect the FreeCAD code of conduct!
Be nice to others! Respect the FreeCAD code of conduct!