Path of pocket with inclined sidewalls
Forum rules
Be nice to others! Respect the FreeCAD code of conduct!
Be nice to others! Respect the FreeCAD code of conduct!
Path of pocket with inclined sidewalls
Hi there,
is there a way to make a path of a pocket with inclined side walls using the path module without using the surfacing tool?
I have something like this in mind: Thanks a lot, best
Patrick
is there a way to make a path of a pocket with inclined side walls using the path module without using the surfacing tool?
I have something like this in mind: Thanks a lot, best
Patrick
Re: Path of pocket with inclined sidewalls
Hi Patrick,
for "something like this" you need a 5 Axis machine, Path WB makes (in this time) only pathes for 3 Axis machines.
for "something like this" you need a 5 Axis machine, Path WB makes (in this time) only pathes for 3 Axis machines.
Gruß Herbert
- sliptonic
- Veteran
- Posts: 3459
- Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2011 10:46 pm
- Location: Columbia, Missouri
- Contact:
Re: Path of pocket with inclined sidewalls
This shape could be approximated with a 3 Axis machine and a ball end mill. The path is theoretically possible with the tools we have now but we don't have an operation that can do pocketing on inclined walls yet.pleid wrote:Hi there,
is there a way to make a path of a pocket with inclined side walls using the path module without using the surfacing tool?
I have something like this in mind:
pocket-inclined-sidewalls.png
Thanks a lot, best
Patrick
Re: Path of pocket with inclined sidewalls
Hard to say just looking at the png.pleid wrote:...way to make a path of a pocket with inclined side walls using the path module without using the surfacing...
What is the incline angle?
What are the dimensions?
With the right tooling, I think it is possible depending on the dims!
What is your stock material: Alum, steel, plastic, brass, etc. ?
Can you post the file? -- I would like to take a crack at it; I can think of one possible way to complete.
Tolerances?
Just remember, FreeCAD_Path is not a computerized machinist; its another set of tools at the machinist's disposal!
Re: Path of pocket with inclined sidewalls
Hi all, thanks a lot for your replies!
I am totally aware, that I will only get an estimation of the surface with my 3-axis machine, and that is fine for me. A rough, stair-cased surface is fine form me as well.
I have attached the file, but I will not make exactly this part. It is just a demo structure for me to compare different CAM programs.
In the end I would like to do a more complicated structure but with inclined walls. The final part will be made out of PVC.
I am totally aware, that I will only get an estimation of the surface with my 3-axis machine, and that is fine for me. A rough, stair-cased surface is fine form me as well.
I have attached the file, but I will not make exactly this part. It is just a demo structure for me to compare different CAM programs.
In the end I would like to do a more complicated structure but with inclined walls. The final part will be made out of PVC.
- Attachments
-
- pocket-v04.fcstd
- (18.05 KiB) Downloaded 60 times
Re: Path of pocket with inclined sidewalls
Hi Bill,
in my mind and like sliptonic wrote, more like abroximate to cone isn't possible with a 3 Axis machine. Also if you have a tool with corresponding angle it does not fit in the corners.
If you accept a abroximate, which means there are steps (Surface roughness) on the surface of the cone, it works if you make the solid (part) with this steps to. Then you have horizontal levels and you can use the pocket operation for it.
I did it one time at this way, but its a lot auf work to make the solid so much steps, that it's realy is a abroximate....
in my mind and like sliptonic wrote, more like abroximate to cone isn't possible with a 3 Axis machine. Also if you have a tool with corresponding angle it does not fit in the corners.
If you accept a abroximate, which means there are steps (Surface roughness) on the surface of the cone, it works if you make the solid (part) with this steps to. Then you have horizontal levels and you can use the pocket operation for it.
I did it one time at this way, but its a lot auf work to make the solid so much steps, that it's realy is a abroximate....
Gruß Herbert
-
- Veteran
- Posts: 2190
- Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2017 10:55 am
Re: Path of pocket with inclined sidewalls
I thought it was going to be easy for my new Path.Area. Boy, was I wrong. Those fillet edges turn out to be BSpline. I've never really tested non-circular curves. It took me a whole day to fix. It was those OCC bug thing, I think, which is why Part didn't use BRepAlgoAPI_Section for cross section. I should have read their code more carefully. Anyway, here you go. You can try my branch at here.
Simply select 'Cube' in the tree view, then 'Cut'. Go to Path, select 'Create area from shape'. Change Operation to 'Difference', Set SectionCount to -1, PocketMode to ZigZag. Then select the FeatureArea in treeview, and click 'Create Path from shape' on Path toolbar. Done!
Simply select 'Cube' in the tree view, then 'Cut'. Go to Path, select 'Create area from shape'. Change Operation to 'Difference', Set SectionCount to -1, PocketMode to ZigZag. Then select the FeatureArea in treeview, and click 'Create Path from shape' on Path toolbar. Done!
Re: Path of pocket with inclined sidewalls
Is this operation "Shock and Awe" ? I think it is time to get accusomed to this Git-stuff.
Is there a possibility to change the direction of the diagonal path segments as well? For production I would like to have at least four goes, one for each side.
Is there a possibility to change the direction of the diagonal path segments as well? For production I would like to have at least four goes, one for each side.
A Sketcher Lecture with in-depth information is available in English, auf Deutsch, en français, en español.
Re: Path of pocket with inclined sidewalls
What is the computation time to generate this Path, Mr Thunder?
I dont have Path.Area installed. Could you generate a path for the inverted LOFT Object from the stock block below? Thanks!
I dont have Path.Area installed. Could you generate a path for the inverted LOFT Object from the stock block below? Thanks!
Re: Path of pocket with inclined sidewalls
Yes, a 45 degree cutting tool; Not as cool as 3D Surfacing, but faster and more accurate per the speed increase.pleid wrote:is there a way to make a path of a pocket with inclined side walls using the path module without using the surfacing tool?