Say if I were to design a part, which comprises of:
* solids that are made by CNC, 3D printing or casting;
* sheetmetal processed by lasercutting, waterjet cutting or photo etching followed by folding; and
* soldering and/or welding of the above parts together to form the finished part
then an assembly of parts by loose, transitional or interference fit.
For solids, obviously I will start with Parts and PartDesign workbenches.
However, for sheetmetal where I design the needed parts, then place the parts onto a sheet for lasercutting or photoetching to get optimal placements, and to simulate folding of the cut parts before assembly, what are the best tools?
Also, in the case of photoetching, one of the common way to easily get folding right is to half-etch along the line to be folded, if the edge radius is so small that it is close to the thickness of the sheetmetal. Then when the part is folded, it tends to fold along that line.
So what is the best workflow to design such an assembly? If we can do this well, then FreeCAD can be a great tool to design kits for model locomotives
Designing model locomotive kits using Assembly and other workbenches
Forum rules
Be nice to others! Respect the FreeCAD code of conduct!
Be nice to others! Respect the FreeCAD code of conduct!
Re: Designing model locomotive kits using Assembly and other workbenches
Uh, a lot of things in your post!
No one has dared to answer yet, so I try.
This is as good as I would, with a preference for PartDesign (very personal).
There is Sheetmetal WB, which I have not yet had the opportunity to test.
https://wiki.freecadweb.org/SheetMetal_Workbench
Regarding the assembly WB, there are 3. It is up to you to choose the one that best suits your expectations.
https://wiki.freecadweb.org/A2plus_Workbench
https://wiki.freecadweb.org/Assembly3_Workbench
https://wiki.freecadweb.org/Assembly4_Workbench
Very personal opinion again, I really like working with Assembly 3 WB.
My website : http://help-freecad-jpg87.fr updated 2023/11/06
Re: Designing model locomotive kits using Assembly and other workbenches
Your design workflow should start by talking to the suppliers (I am assuming you will outsource)
Here an example:
https://www.ppdltd.com/artwork-guide.html
There is a lot more to model photo etch than simply sheetmetal WB in FreeCAD
Re: Designing model locomotive kits using Assembly and other workbenches
ah true...... thanks for your pointer.bambuko wrote: ↑Fri May 07, 2021 11:38 amYour design workflow should start by talking to the suppliers (I am assuming you will outsource)
Here an example:
https://www.ppdltd.com/artwork-guide.html
There is a lot more to model photo etch than simply sheetmetal WB in FreeCAD
So what is the best workbench/workflow for creating assemblies that features photo-etched sheetmetal? Is it still shetmetal workbench? would be nice of sheetmetal workbench if apart from subtraction (cutting through) and folding, it also have etch function where you can specify areas of half edge from each side
Re: Designing model locomotive kits using Assembly and other workbenches
perhaps it would be nice...?
but probably too complicated?
Most of the guys doing it use something like https://qcad.org/en/ to produce vector file formats required by etching people.
I am not using sheetmetal workbench for my project (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KISS_principle),
but would be very interested how you get on - share with us your models and results?
-
- Posts: 225
- Joined: Fri Apr 26, 2019 3:14 pm
Re: Designing model locomotive kits using Assembly and other workbenches
Hi all,
when I first had a look at FreeCad I also thought that sheet-metal might be good to make brass-etching-templates.
But I think the WB is designated to an other goal in mind.
What would be needed would be an unfolding mechanism which keeps track on corners (bendig grooves) where during etching a lower thickness/etching is needed to facilitate the bending during the assembley of the etched elements ....
https://www.themt.de/mt-0170-etch2-49.html
Also one would need a cut-mechanism to extract the unfolded structures-to-be-exported to dxf/pdf
Regards,
Stefan
when I first had a look at FreeCad I also thought that sheet-metal might be good to make brass-etching-templates.
But I think the WB is designated to an other goal in mind.
What would be needed would be an unfolding mechanism which keeps track on corners (bendig grooves) where during etching a lower thickness/etching is needed to facilitate the bending during the assembley of the etched elements ....
https://www.themt.de/mt-0170-etch2-49.html
Also one would need a cut-mechanism to extract the unfolded structures-to-be-exported to dxf/pdf
Regards,
Stefan
Re: Designing model locomotive kits using Assembly and other workbenches
You are right.... So is the unfolding mechanism and the cut mechanism best implemented in the sheetmetal workbench, or in another possibly new workbench?C_h_o_p_i_n wrote: ↑Mon Aug 23, 2021 11:20 am Hi all,
when I first had a look at FreeCad I also thought that sheet-metal might be good to make brass-etching-templates.
But I think the WB is designated to an other goal in mind.
What would be needed would be an unfolding mechanism which keeps track on corners (bendig grooves) where during etching a lower thickness/etching is needed to facilitate the bending during the assembley of the etched elements ....
https://www.themt.de/mt-0170-etch2-49.html
Also one would need a cut-mechanism to extract the unfolded structures-to-be-exported to dxf/pdf
Regards,
Stefan
And do you know how the design and simulation of the etched sheetmetal done in other CAM software such as Solidworks?
Thx!