Villa Savoye - IFC Missing Window & Opening
Villa Savoye - IFC Missing Window & Opening
Hi, I have been testing my workflow with modelling a few hypothetical or famous building.
With modeling of Villa Savoye at Villa Savoye - FC Model, trying to export to IFC to test.
Found a strange situation, 4 strip window on 4 facades, only 1 strip window at front elevation and opening missing ?
(Ifc opened in IFC++ on fedora 30)
Not know if it is FC / IFCexport / IFC++ / my modelling / etc. problem ?
Model posted at GitHub / simplified version discussion thread.
[EDIT - IFCexport with the Facades/Window's only ]
With modeling of Villa Savoye at Villa Savoye - FC Model, trying to export to IFC to test.
Found a strange situation, 4 strip window on 4 facades, only 1 strip window at front elevation and opening missing ?
(Ifc opened in IFC++ on fedora 30)
Not know if it is FC / IFCexport / IFC++ / my modelling / etc. problem ?
Model posted at GitHub / simplified version discussion thread.
[EDIT - IFCexport with the Facades/Window's only ]
- Attachments
-
- Villa Savoye_1F_partial_facade.ifc
- (167.75 KiB) Downloaded 72 times
-
- Villa Savoye_1F_partial.ifc
- (274.85 KiB) Downloaded 70 times
Re: Villa Savoye - IFC Missing Window & Opening
Suddenly something comes to my attention, I might have seen this and reported before?
The 'front' strip window has a Clone, and used it as the 'rear' strip window.
I guess IFCexport ignore the 1st 'instance', the original one !!!
Previous case maybe Clones of doors.
The 'front' strip window has a Clone, and used it as the 'rear' strip window.
I guess IFCexport ignore the 1st 'instance', the original one !!!
Previous case maybe Clones of doors.
Re: Villa Savoye - IFC Missing Window & Opening
for me the window is missing if the FreeCAD file will be opened. An missing window can not be exported to ifc ...
Re: Villa Savoye - IFC Missing Window & Opening
BTW: if I open the file I get lots of
Code: Select all
<string>(1)<class 'ModuleNotFoundError'>: No module named 'ArchSketchObject'
Re: Villa Savoye - IFC Missing Window & Opening
Thanks for checking.
The side elevation you are looking at open into internal courtyard / open space so there is no windows.
Instead, it is the 'front elevation' the whole width of strip window and its opening are missing.
Re: Villa Savoye - IFC Missing Window & Opening
See https://forum.freecadweb.org/viewtopic. ... 10#p354185bernd wrote: ↑Mon Jan 13, 2020 11:16 am BTW: if I open the file I get lots of
Code: Select all
<string>(1)<class 'ModuleNotFoundError'>: No module named 'ArchSketchObject'
This is experimental, being tested in the workflow modelling the buildings, do not need it if the model is not recomputed.
Re: Villa Savoye - IFC Missing Window & Opening
ok in regard of the error.
But if there is no window tha there is no window missing ...
But if there is no window tha there is no window missing ...
Re: Villa Savoye - IFC Missing Window & Opening
It is another window Win_1F_win_Front in the 'front elevation' that is missing in the IFC.
Many windows
FC model
Window in concern highlighted
Compare the one in IFC below
IFC Model
Just a blank wall,
w/o opening
w/o window
?
Many windows
FC model
Window in concern highlighted
Compare the one in IFC below
IFC Model
Just a blank wall,
w/o opening
w/o window
?
Re: Villa Savoye - IFC Missing Window & Opening
I may have a look at the exporter. Would it be possible to share a much simpler FreeCAD file which shows the problem?
Re: Villa Savoye - IFC Missing Window & Opening
Thanks looking into this.
- Attachments
-
- Villa Savoye_1F_Facade.FCStd
- (388.67 KiB) Downloaded 67 times