[Feature request] (Sketcher Constraints) A single Dimension tool for all types
Forum rules
Be nice to others! Read the FreeCAD code of conduct!
Be nice to others! Read the FreeCAD code of conduct!
[Feature request] (Sketcher Constraints) A single Dimension tool for all types
Hi has anyone been working on a feature to just have a single dimension tool for the most common ones Horizontal, Vertical, Diagonal, Circular and Angles?
If not would it be difficult to implement?
If not would it be difficult to implement?
- Attachments
-
- freecaddim.jpg (3.62 KiB) Viewed 2302 times
Last edited by jmaustpc on Sat Sep 26, 2020 8:06 am, edited 1 time in total.
Reason: Added "(Sketcher Constraints)" to topic title
Reason: Added "(Sketcher Constraints)" to topic title
Re: [Feature request] A single Dimension tool for all types
I don't think so and I don't want it. They do different things, easy to be seen on a diagonal line.
A Sketcher Lecture with in-depth information is available in English, auf Deutsch, en français, en español.
Re: [Feature request] A single Dimension tool for all types
I think it would be great to have one. Before that i think the Dimensions should have a update. The Dimensions are quite sensitive what type user input is accepted.
The Horizontal dimension and vertical dimension are quite rigid.
* With this way of working a extra click is required to finish (place) the dimension. but compared to every time i get a popup where i choose horizontal dimension and select a vertical line (both reason misclick of a point or because of that creo, NX and SW accept the previous described method ...).
Ps. For now you can use the diagonal arrow also for horizontal and vertical lines if you want too. This as long as there vertical or horizontal line need to be attached.
The Horizontal dimension and vertical dimension are quite rigid.
- select first a line and a dimension appear.
- Select first a point you have to select another point
* With this way of working a extra click is required to finish (place) the dimension. but compared to every time i get a popup where i choose horizontal dimension and select a vertical line (both reason misclick of a point or because of that creo, NX and SW accept the previous described method ...).
Ps. For now you can use the diagonal arrow also for horizontal and vertical lines if you want too. This as long as there vertical or horizontal line need to be attached.
Re: [Feature request] A single Dimension tool for all types
I have moved to add horizontal and vertical distance constraints with the hotkeys, and I don't look back. I rarely use distance constraint, which may depend on the models I make.
Edit in blue.
Edit in blue.
A Sketcher Lecture with in-depth information is available in English, auf Deutsch, en français, en español.
Re: [Feature request] A single Dimension tool for all types
The constraints are out of scope i think. It is more about the dimensioning tool.
I try tonight add a small video what shows a NX example(i could do the same with Creo or SW but current project use NX so that's the most easy pick )
I try tonight add a small video what shows a NX example(i could do the same with Creo or SW but current project use NX so that's the most easy pick )
Re: [Feature request] A single Dimension tool for all types
I am fully aware other software has other ways of presenting dimension tools.
But, I have yet to actually understand what is being proposed here and why it would make my work in FC easier, quicker, etc.
Clicking the icon for the type of constraint I desire and clicking two objects to apply it to seems pretty easy and straightforward to me.
Clicking two objects and clicking the type of constraint I desire between the two seems just as easy.
What am I missing?
There are specific reasons to have horizontal, vertical, and distance constraints. Why would I not want them all?
But, I have yet to actually understand what is being proposed here and why it would make my work in FC easier, quicker, etc.
Clicking the icon for the type of constraint I desire and clicking two objects to apply it to seems pretty easy and straightforward to me.
Clicking two objects and clicking the type of constraint I desire between the two seems just as easy.
What am I missing?
There are specific reasons to have horizontal, vertical, and distance constraints. Why would I not want them all?
Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan: Spock: "...His pattern indicates two-dimensional thinking."
- Pauvres_honteux
- Posts: 728
- Joined: Sun Feb 16, 2014 12:05 am
- Location: Far side of the moon
Re: [Feature request] A single Dimension tool for all types
Just wanted to point out that you're definitely not alone in your request!
(click on the tiny up-arrow to the right of "wrote:")
If I remember correctly, he who did most of the programming said he had it on his radar. But that was some years ago...Pauvres_honteux wrote: ↑Sun Feb 16, 2014 12:48 am Hi, I have a wish of getting a constraints creation tool that consists/contains of all possible constraints commands avaible and starts running after double clicking a general constraints icon.
Good things is it's programed in C++ = fast execution.
Bad thing is it's programmed in C++ = stops anyone with only Python knowledge to progress this. And the vast majority in this fora seems to be Pythonistas.
But maybe some merciful soul can point out how to do programming for the sketcher in pure Python? I'm sure it would help with progress. When something is fully done it can be translated to C++ by a skilled C-wizard! We all want lightning fast code, right? MIT Fast code seminar
Re: [Feature request] A single Dimension tool for all types
Basically we have 3 constraints that do basically the same thing... The request is one(1) tool that handle ALL dimensions.
I hope after tonight the request is a bit more clear
Re: [Feature request] A single Dimension tool for all types
I have edited my post above, and still think that using the hot keys is even faster. Even if a line is horizontal you may for special reasons want to have a length constraint instead of horizontal distance - e.g. for animation purposes. So you would have to be offered both possibilities and you have to make a decision in some way.
A Sketcher Lecture with in-depth information is available in English, auf Deutsch, en français, en español.
Re: [Feature request] A single Dimension tool for all types
How is vertical, horizontal and distance the same thing?
Horizontal constrains the horizontal distance between two objects. Vertical constrains the vertical distance between two objects. Distance sets the distance between two objects. Please explain what I'm missing?
Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan: Spock: "...His pattern indicates two-dimensional thinking."