I'm happy to share the second commit of a future full iconTheme replacement for FreeCAD.
Dark and Light themes screenshots and some combinations with other stylesheets:
demo.png (222.31 KiB) Viewed 5982 times
It does need @triplus IconThemes module in order to work (for more information on the subject follow this forum thread) and I prevent you it's still in heavy development so, by now, you will only find new icons for Part Design workbench... but more icons will come in near future, of course.
I am eager to try it ASAP. But on the other hand i feel that as you have put much design work in it i will likely test it over the weekend. As then i will have more time for a proper first test and i guess a whole new FreeCAD icon experience.
P.S. Just looking at the screenshots looking good!
The icons i added green dot don't work for me. Some are really nice like cut, undo/redo, refresh... I don't know if i will use pure monochrome version therefore i can always fix that myself as seen on the rectangle icon. Likely just for the tools i use frequently and the rest will stay monochrome. Contrast between active and inactive commands is not all that big and i like a bit of color in the end. There were discussions on the forum about polyline icon and i feel you should go for that. That is to use combination of a line and an arc instead of just lines.
Beyond that looking good and i see i have some work still to do with the IconThemes module.
I will have a look at them when redesigning (in fact, lot of them had been redesigned before releasing) and fine tuning.
It also happend to me that it was a big jump from the regular colored icons to the monochrome ones, but with little time you get used to them and you like them. Anyway, I also found that disabled icons are still too much visible for my taste and this effect is much more present with Simple monochrome theme than with regular colored one. It's a "simple tweak" that I would suggest to apply to regular FreeCAD that, in addition, will help Simple theme to have more contrast between enabled and disabled buttons.
On the dark theme the contrast for the dark icon scheme looks much better. Therefore i guess focusing on if this could be slightly improved for the light theme could make sense? As if i would be using dark color scheme likely i would be fine with the contrast.
And as for the color. Distinguishing Draft Line to Sketcher Line could be made easier in the future... How about if you would provide monochrome version of light and dark icon theme and additional variant with some color added? That is minimal color added and likely in sync with original command color scheme? I would be very interesting in seeing how would you approach this and what would the result be.
And as for the icons for entering and exiting the sketcher edit mode. Do you think having arrow (up/down) instead of brush/x would make sense? As currently the step from default command icon to new design is big and i don't see much benefit in it.
As for the rest (and what i didn't mention in the previous post) i have been using the icons for a day and they are working good.