FEA solver vs. FreeCAD FEM

[bernd]

I added a wiki page about all various kind of solvers. https://www.freecadweb.org/wiki/FEM_Solver

I remember two disscussions I'm not able to find. One was about a solver wich could calculate penetrations like a cannonball into a wall, and the other was about a FEM solver developed in Čech republic. May be some other remembers these topics better than me.

Can we categorize all the FEM pages by adding them to a [[Category:FEM]] ?

Do we have categories for other modules on the wiki already? If yes we really should do this!

[bernd]

Object oriented finite element solver http://www.oofem.org/

added. Do you remember the solver for analyzing bullets and stuff like this which gos into some other material.

[saso]

I remember two disscussions I'm not able to find. One was about a solver wich could calculate penetrations like a cannonball into a wall,

http://www.impact-fem.org/

and the other was about a FEM solver developed in Čech republic.

http://www.hpfem.org/hermes/ (http://www.agros2d.org/)

[kkremitzki]

and the other was about a FEM solver developed in Čech republic.

http://www.hpfem.org/hermes/ (http://www.agros2d.org/)

Wow, now that's one that really needs to be in Debian Science!

[bernd]

added them too ...

[Kunda1]

I added a wiki page about all various kind of solvers. https://www.freecadweb.org/wiki/FEM_Solver

I remember two disscussions I'm not able to find. One was about a solver wich could calculate penetrations like a cannonball into a wall, and the other was about a FEM solver developed in Čech republic. May be some other remembers these topics better than me.

Can we categorize all the FEM pages by adding them to a [[Category:FEM]] ?

Do we have categories for other modules on the wiki already? If yes we really should do this!

This is currently off topic so I'll create another thread, reference this one and ping you. Thanks
New topic created @ https://forum.freecadweb.org/viewtopic.php?f=21&t=31424

[saso]

Thanks for the wiki bernd and nice to see the support for all this solvers. IMO in FOSS it is important to have a variety of choices. Here are a few more solvers for the possible future

code aster https://www.code-aster.org/
code saturne https://www.code-saturne.org
hermes (agros) http://www.hpfem.org/hermes/ (http://www.agros2d.org/)
nastran https://github.com/nasa/NASTRAN-95
su2 https://su2code.github.io/

take note also about code saturne and su2, they are both for CFD

[bernd]

Thanks for the wiki bernd and nice to see the support for all this solvers.

I will for sure not support all this solver! It would take ages to develop ...

[saso]

Thanks for the wiki bernd and nice to see the support for all this solvers.

I will for sure not support all this solver! It would take ages to develop ...

Yes, of course not It was not meant that all of it should be implemented by the end of the year, just to have a list where one can come back to later if there is a need or wish for something else.

[Kunda1]

FYI, it may be good to being getting FreeCAD FEMs 3rd party deps more established in the package ecosystem:

FreeCAD-FEM-3rd-Party-deps.png (198.03 KiB) Viewed 4827 times

Maybe this needs to be a separate thread?