Buffalo Springfield steam road roller

[un1corn]

Buffalo Springfield steam road roller Ca 1924 also known as 'Coffee pot'
I put this together around April 2019 took around 4 weeks to complete, quite an interesting model to generate.
Freecad V16 used at that time with Assembly2 WB
Plans from JDW, http://www.vapeuretmodelesavapeur.com/telechargements4/
The assembly file is 17+MB and so is to large to include here.

[alberich]

Fantastic!

Did you use an assembly WB in v0.16?

[un1corn]

Yes, as noted above I used Assembly 2 WB

[ppemawm]

Buffalo Springfield steam road roller...

Thanks for sharing another of your awesome models. I know full well how much work has to go into these.
Well done.

Have you ever thought about creating all the bodies in a single file at their proper location in the assembly?
You might enjoy more the in-context "design" process. No assembly workbench required !

[-alex-]

Very nice model, well done and thanks for sharing!

[alberich]

Yes, as noted above I used Assembly 2 WB

Heh. I was so fascinated by your images I missed the words.

[mfasano]

Have you ever thought about creating all the bodies in a single file at their proper location in the assembly?
You might enjoy more the in-context "design" process. No assembly workbench required !

I have seen that you are playing with assembly4. How does that compare to creating a model as you describe above?

[ppemawm]

Freecad V16 used at that time with Assembly2 WB

Have you ever thought about creating all the bodies in a single file at their proper location in the assembly?

I have seen that you are playing with assembly4. How does that compare to creating a model as you describe above?

The Assembly4 workbench facilitates the top-down assembly design process wherein all the parts can be created in-context in the same file, typically constrained by an assembly master sketch. The parts are attached to each other using local coordinate systems so that if one must move then the rest follow. The constraints and solver in the master sketch control how the parts move in relation to each other. Top-down design works well for design of original, custom, bespoke, or prototype parts and their assembly.

AFAIK un1corn uses a bottom-up approach wherein parts are created in separate files, imported to an assembly file, and then placed and constrained in their proper position using the A2plus assembly workbench. The assembly constraints and its solver define how the parts react if one or more are moved. Bottom up assembly is useful for predefined parts, reused parts and standard parts such as fasteners, in an assembly arrangement that is known beforehand.

[fc_tofu]

...
The Assembly4 workbench facilitates the top-down assembly design process wherein all the parts can be created in-context in the same file, typically constrained by an assembly master sketch. The parts are attached to each other using local coordinate systems so that if one must move then the rest follow. The constraints and solver in the master sketch control how the parts move in relation to each other. Top-down design works well for design of original, custom, bespoke, or prototype parts and their assembly.

AFAIK un1corn uses a bottom-up approach wherein parts are created in separate files, imported to an assembly file, and then placed and constrained in their proper position using the A2plus assembly workbench. The assembly constraints and its solver define how the parts react if one or more are moved. Bottom up assembly is useful for predefined parts, reused parts and standard parts such as fasteners, in an assembly arrangement that is known beforehand.

Thanks.

[fc_tofu]

Buffalo Springfield steam road roller Ca 1924 also known as 'Coffee pot'
...

Beautiful.

Can you show a TreeView and a dependency graph screenshot?